Hero Illustration - Homepage
City Guides

The 5 Best Hamptons Coffee Shops That You Have to Visit

Adeel Mallick

Are you a new home owner in the Hamptons or a coffee lover visiting the area? Coffee is an essential part of many morning routines, and a good cup of coffee can help you start the day on a good note. 

Whether you like your coffee iced, hot, or frozen, we’ve compiled a list of the top 5 Hamptons coffee shops that you have to try!

1. Left Hand Coffee - 83 South Elmwood Avenue, Montauk

Left Hand Coffee is a locally-owned, eclectic Hamptons coffee shop that’s open from 8 am to 3 pm from Monday to Thursday, with later hours on the weekends. They offer a decadent array of coffee choices such as pour-overs, americanos, plain drip, cappuccinos, flavored lattes (like the Nutella latte), and more.

Each coffee blend is named after local historical places and surfing spots. Left Hand uses coffee beans from countries that produce quality, tasty beans and that are some of the best surfing destinations in the world. Their coffee is organic, and the shop’s interior is an inviting and cozy spot for all coffee lovers.

2. Sagtown Coffee - 78 Main Street, Sag Harbor

Sagtown Coffee is a Hampton coffee shop favorite that’s open from 6 am to 5 pm every day. They offer online ordering from 6 am to 4:30 pm daily so that patrons in a rush can get their coffee quickly. 

They offer a variety of hot espresso drinks, from lattes to cappuccinos to cortados. If you’re hoping for something iced and sweet, you can snag an iced caramel macchiato, matcha latte, or an iced sutra gold superfood latte. 

Sagtown exclusively offers La Colombe coffee and coffee beans because of the roast’s in-depth flavors. Whether you’re in a rush or you’re looking to get some work done, Sagtown coffee is one of the Hamptons coffee shops you must visit.

3. The Hampton Coffee Company - Multiple locations in the Hamptons

The Hampton Coffee Company has become a landmark for coffee lovers visiting and residing in the Hamptons. This staple coffee shop has been around since the 1940s and is one of the first micro-roasters on the East Coast.

They roast their own quality coffee beans and have expanded their locations across Long Island. You can purchase iced or hot coffee drinks such as frozen mochas, cappuccinos, cortados, and more.

If you want to try a unique assortment of coffee roasts, then visit the Hampton Coffee Company to try their authentic, proprietary blend.

4. Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee - 146 Montauk, Hwy Amagansett

Founded in 2003, Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee serves organic, ethically-sourced coffee. This family-run coffee shop has expanded from one location to ten locations in New York, including the Hamptons.

At this Hamptons coffee shop, you can find delicious shade-grown coffee that’s been grown by farmers and purveyors who have partnered with the coffee shop. The name “The Stir” comes from how they stir the coffee grounds in water in order to get an even, balanced brew and a high quality extraction of flavor. 

They also have a delicious assortment of vegan baked goods available for purchase.

5. Ralph’s Coffee - 41 Jobs Ln, Southampton

Ralph’s coffee has its own assortment of special blend coffee roasts ranging from regular to decaf to espresso. Their flavorful coffee beans have been organically grown from a variety of countries in Central America, South America, and Africa. 

Their unique, high scale locations are a part of the Ralph Lauren brand, and you can expect to find classic interior designs with rich colors. When you’re in the Hamptons, going to one of the many Ralph’s locations is a must-do.

There are a variety of Hamptons coffee options to choose from when you visit or reside in the city. We hope this list satisfies your coffee cravings. Let us know which one is your favorite!

Join our monthly newsletter

Enter your email address below to subscribe to our monthly newsletter.
Thank you! You have been subscribed to our blog.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
House IllustrationHouse Illustration